Nothing makes an educator more nervous than taking students
out of the school and into the world on a field trip. The stakes are
particularly higher when the students are 6th graders and the field
trip is to a historical museum full of irreplaceable and valuable artifacts,
involves a walk through a downtown urban area, and a meal at a restaurant
during lunch hour. This was the position that I placed myself in last month.
During a college class last semester, I learned of a local history museum that
had received an endowment from a patron that covered the cost of buses for
student field trips to the museum. I am quite interested in local history and
wish to impart some of it onto my students, regardless of their own interest. I
believe that people should know something about the history of where they live
and that 12 year old human beings are desperate to figure out just where they
fit into this wide wacky world. Local history can help put a person in context.
I
suggested to the 6th grade team at my placement school that this
museum would be a prime location for a field trip. The idea was accepted and my
stress level began to rise. A few blocks worth of walk to a small city park
decorated by sculptures was added to the field trip itinerary, as was a meal at
a restaurant. Details were hammered out over the following month and the day of
the trip was upon us when I realized just how worried I was. I was afraid that
my students would not be interested in the material. I was afraid that my
students might act like fools outside of the classroom. I was afraid that my
colleagues would consider my idea of visiting the museum to have been a
horrible mistake once we were there. I was very afraid that my students might
accidentally or intentionally cause damage to an irreplaceable artifact. I was
afraid that my students would embarrass the teachers and school with poor
behavior at the museum. I was afraid that something bad might happen during the
walk through downtown. I was afraid of a million variables. Why had I suggested
this trip?
As it
turned out, the students were not riveted by the material in the museum. But,
they behaved well and did not cause any problems (or damage thank God) during
our time there. The walk to the sculpture park was anticlimactic. Students got
loud, but they had spent two hours being told to hush in a museum and we were
outside. I was beginning to think that all of my worries had been in error.
Then we went to lunch…
One
teacher and I somehow were put in charge of over 60 6th graders in a
fast food restaurant. The food ordering process was slow and painful, but our
students had been advised to bring lunch money and they all made their way
through the line. A warning phone call had been made to the restaurant manager
the previous day, but he still was sweating the influx of adolescence into his
eatery. One student dropped his food and
it was replaced at no charge (probably out of fear of a riot.) I ordered my own
food and took a spot near the back of the restaurant where a few of my more
troublesome students were eating and chatting. It was then that I noticed a man
sitting alone at a booth.
One
student approached me and whispered “That guy is homeless. He’s making a sign
that says ‘Homeless- please help’.” That student was discreet, however many of
my students were not. Soon several of them were walking by the man’s booth and
staring at him before slipping back to their peers and snickering. My
Spidey-sense began to tingle.
One student with whom I have had
constant issues due to his immaturity was sitting at a table near the man. He
watched as his classmates acted distastefully. Suddenly he spoke. “That ain’t
right y’all. That could be you someday. That’s messed up, you acting like
that.” I nearly stood and applauded this uncharacteristic display of maturity.
Instead, I beckoned him to my table and he hesitantly came over. Before he
could ruin the moment by defending himself, I told him how proud he had just
made me. “You just proved to me that you are a kind and mature young man.” He
shrugged off my compliment and pulled a couple of dollar bills from his pocket.
“Can I give him this?” I asked him to leave it at my table and told him that I
would give it to the man when we left to “avoid making a scene.” He nodded
approval and left the money on my table.
Suddenly, several students
approached my table as if they had all been privy to the conversation. Before I
knew it, fifteen or so dollar bills and a handful of change sat before me. Ours
is a school where 86% of the students are economically disadvantaged. These are
poor children. But they wanted to give what they could give to help this man. When
the time came for us to leave the restaurant I took the offerings in my hand
and approached the man. “Here. My 6th grade students wanted you to
have this.” I said. “Thank you” he said. “God bless them.” Before I knew it he continued “Nice to know
they aren’t rude like SOME PEOPLE!” He turned and glared at a few of our 6th
grade girls who had been less than considerate with their behavior.
“Let’s go.” I nervously barked and
gestured to the girls whose eyes had tripled in size. Though they never follow
orders without retort, they listened to me in that instance. We all left the
restaurant.
My heart was in my throat as I
followed the last student onto the bus to return to school. I had every right
to be fearful of the activities of that day. But I had been given a glimpse of
hope for the future.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete-edited for spelling-
ReplyDeleteWell-written. Great language. This is a beautiful and real story. Phrases such as "influx of adolescence into his eatery" flow off the tongue, and sound like they're out of an early 90's hip-hop track. Your lessons and stories always seem to be composed of something greater than the day-to-day - its folks like you who can/are/will/have redeemed this profession. I think Pleasant Valley (that's where you're teaching next year, right?) has just gotten a very lucky draft pick.
Great post! I haven't had the experience of taking students in public yet, but I'm sure it will happen someday. When you mentioned that you didn't feel they were particularly moved by the material in the museum I was reminded that I have discovered SEVERAL times this semester that what students learn often has nothing to do with the subject matter. I think your students' lesson was for them to encounter someone who lived a different life than they did and to show respect as humans. That may not have been the purpose of your lesson that day, but you are a social studies teacher, and students need to learn how to treat other people. It sounds like all of your students learned something about that. I bet a lot of students don't have parents who teach them how to behave in a public setting (I know many of mine behave that way). For you to take them in public and trust them to behave is also a great lesson.
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing!
Lindsay
Erich, thank you for sharing this experience so vividly and meaningfully. This deserves a wider audience.
ReplyDelete